Colt Alton

August 20, 2024

The Hidden Playbook of Leadership

Receiving the Harvard Business Review in the mail is exciting. It promises fresh insights, innovative ideas, and thought-provoking content that can shift our approach to work and leadership. But this month, there was an added layer of interest. 

The feature article was written by Tom Brady, one of the greatest individual players in football history. Regardless of where you stand on the debate about Brady’s place among the all-time greats, his impressive career stats are undeniable.

In high-stakes environments like professional sports or business, leadership often focuses on individual brilliance—the star player, the visionary CEO, the one who stands out. But here’s the paradox: Tom Brady, a seven-time Super Bowl champion celebrated for his individual achievements, offers a perspective that may surprise many. He emphasizes that real success isn’t about individual accolades; it’s about team dynamics.

Brady’s message is clear: impactful leaders understand and harness the collective power of their teams. This insight is important for leaders striving to maximize their impact. As I read the article, it struck me how these principles could extend beyond the football field, influencing leadership and success in business.

Brady's Principles: A New Leadership Lens


Brady breaks down the essence of effective team leadership, outlining seven principles applicable in the boardroom and on the field. Here are key takeaways for every leader:

  1. Prioritizing Collective Success in a 'Me-First' Culture
    True leadership begins with prioritizing the collective over the individual. Personal branding on platforms like LinkedIn and Twitter is often emphasized, but Brady argues for putting team success first. Companies like Patagonia and Zappos have shown that this approach leads to remarkable outcomes.

    Reflection: How can leaders foster this mentality when individual metrics drive promotions and bonuses?

  2. Recognizing the Unsung in a Star-Obsessed World
    Leadership isn’t just about guiding the star players; it’s also about acknowledging the contributions of those who often go unnoticed. Brady shares how acknowledging the efforts of his offensive linemen and support staff made them feel valued and motivated to give their best. In any organization, appreciating the ‘behind-the-scenes’ players can foster a more committed and engaged workforce.

    Reflection: How can leaders ensure that every team member feels valued, regardless of their visibility?

  3. Setting High Standards in a World of Quick Wins
    Success comes from exceeding expectations, not just meeting them. With pressure for quarterly results and short-term gains, Brady’s insistence on high standards becomes a harbinger of success. Leaders like Jeff Bezos at Amazon have famously focused on long-term value over short-term profits.

    Reflection: How can other leaders instill this kind of patient, excellence-focused culture?

  4. Personalized Motivation in the Age of One-Size-Fits-All HR Policies
    One size doesn't fit all when it comes to motivating a team. Brady's approach to tailored motivation challenges the standardized HR practices many companies rely on. Netflix's famous culture deck emphasizes treating employees as adults and avoiding blanket policies.

    Reflection: How can leaders strike a balance between fair, consistent treatment and personalized motivation?

  5. Complementary Leadership in Traditional Hierarchies
    Great leaders know how to complement the strengths and weaknesses of their formal leaders. Brady’s relationship with Bill Belichick is a perfect example. While Belichick’s leadership was rooted in discipline and accountability, Brady provided the emotional support and camaraderie that the team needed. In any organization, leaders should aim to complement rather than compete with each other’s styles.

    Reflection: How can leaders at different levels of an organization ensure they’re complementing rather than competing with each other?

  6. Managing External Pressures in a Hyper-Connected World Leaders must be aware of external forces that lead to selfish behavior among team members. Leaders should reinforce the team’s objectives and counteract influences that may disrupt unity. Companies like 37signals have taken radical steps to shield their teams from these pressures.

    Reflection: What strategies can leaders use to maintain team focus and cohesion in the face of constant external noise?

  7. Building Trust Beyond the Office

    Finally, Brady underscores the importance of building relationships beyond work. Shared experiences, like team-building events or casual gatherings, foster trust and connection among team members. These bonds are important for navigating challenges and achieving long-term success. Companies like GitLab, which is fully remote, have developed innovative ways to foster team bonding.

    Reflection: How can leaders create on-going meaningful connections with their team, whether they are face-to-face, hybrid, or remote?

The Future of Leadership: Balancing Team and Individual Achievement

Brady's insights argue for the enduring value of emotional intelligence and human connection in leadership. They challenge us to rethink our individualistic approach to business success and consider creating more cohesive, motivated teams.

The modern leader's challenge is clear:

  • How do we foster a team-first mentality while recognizing individual contributions?

  • How do we set high standards without burning out our teams?

  • How do we personalize leadership while maintaining fairness and consistency?

Brady's leadership philosophy isn't just a playbook for sports teams—it's a reminder of the power of collective effort and shared purpose in achieving extraordinary results. In the next decade, the most successful organizations will likely be those that can balance individual excellence with team cohesion and personal accountability with collective responsibility.

In this context, Brady's leadership approach is insightful and potentially transformative. By focusing on the human elements of teamwork, motivation, and shared success, leaders can create organizations that are more successful, fulfilling, and inclusive places to work.

As you navigate the complexities of life and work, take a page from Brady's playbook. Emphasize 'we' over 'I', long-term excellence over short-term gains, and the power of human connection in driving success.

Here's a link to the full article on HBR. Enjoy!

- Stay curious

Colt

About Colt Alton

Hey! I'm Colt. By trade and training, I help develop people and organizations. Subscribe below to follow my thinking on building impactful learning experiences, learning technology and product development, and whatever else is on my mind. Thanks for visiting, thanks for reading.