Ian Mulvany

October 14, 2025

I like the look of Reviewer3

I got a chance to quickly kick the tyres on Reviewer3, and I really like the design approach that they have taken to show how their agents operate together.

I just want to add in a pirate reviewer!

This is https://www.reviewer3.com/ The screenshot is self-explanatory. 


image.png




I've been playing around with AI in peer review myself, and managed to get my own tool to generate this review for a manuscript:

Ahoy, me hearties! This be a review worthy of a scurvy pirate like meself. Let's dive in, shall we?

Ye be talkin' about them smartphones and social media, eh? Well, ye be right that banning 'em ain't the answer, ye scallywags. Them bans be like tryin' to stop a ship from sailin' by takin' away the rudder. Sure, it might work for a bit, but the ship's still goin' to drift and crash eventually.

Ye be talkin' about rights and all that, and I say ye be on the right track, me hearties. Aye, the little ones need to be protected from the dangers of the digital seas, but they also need to learn how to navigate 'em. Teach 'em the skills, give 'em the tools, and let 'em steer their own course, I say.

And this "age appropriate design" ye be talkin' about? Aye, that be a smart idea. Make the apps and websites fit the little ones, not the other way around. Let 'em play and learn without gettin' lost in the endless waves of notifications and clickbait.

As for the education, ye be right that the schools and families need to be involved. Teach 'em how to spot the scurvy tricks of the digital world, how to work together to stay safe, and how to use technology to their advantage. And don't forget the parents - they be the captains of their own ships, and they need to know how to steer their little ones in the right direction.

But ye be right, there be challenges ahead. The tech industry be a bunch of greedy landlubbers, only carin' about their own treasure. And the landlubbers in charge, well, they be more concerned with test scores than with the health and wellbeing of the little ones. It be a tough battle, but one worth fightin', I say.

So hoist the sails, me hearties, and set a course for a healthier, safer digital world for the little ones. Batten down the hatches, keep a weather eye on the horizon, and remember - with the right tools and the right crew, even the stormiest seas can be navigated.

About Ian Mulvany

Hi, I'm Ian - I work on academic publishing systems. You can find out more about me at mulvany.net. I'm always interested in engaging with folk on these topics, if you have made your way here don't hesitate to reach out if there is anything you want to share, discuss, or ask for help with!